with
Maestro
Alfredo Escande from Montevideo (Uruguay)
about
Maestro
Abel Carlevaro and his Guitar-school
by LÉON FRIJNS
CITHARA-Societé Luxembourgeoise de Guitare Classique
first published in CITHARA INFO nº 12-March 2001
Léon Frijns and Alfredo Escande
in Carmelo, April 2001
The
Concert that Maestro Abel Carlevaro is going to give on the 19th of
May in Diekirch gave rise to the following interview with Alfredo Escande.
Alfredo Escande is one of the leading personalities in Uruguayan guitar-world.
He knows Abel Carlevaro well because he worked for many years together with him.
In this interview Alfredo Escande
throws a light upon Carlevaro as a guitarist and upon the guitar school he
developed so thoroughly.
The
interview has been made in March 2001 by Léon Frijns, from Holland. Léon met Alfredo Escande for
the first time in April 2000 in Montevideo.
|
Léon
Frijns: Dear Alfredo, could you tell us something about yourself? |
|
Alfredo
Escande: Well, the first thing that comes to my mind when you ask
me that question is to say that I am a happy man, luckily doing the things
I like most: teaching (guitar
and mathematics), playing the guitar, sharing my life with whom and where
I've chosen, and being in contact with many good friends around the world
(wonderful people, you among them).
|
|
L.F.:
Can you tell us about your way to the guitar? Who was (were) your first
teacher(s)? |
|
A.E.:
My father gave me a guitar as a Christmas present when I was 11
years old, and then I
began to study with my first guitar teacher, Juan Carlos Risso. When I
entered the University (Economics) I had too little time for practising,
but suddenly I realised that I liked music and the guitar too much, so I
decided to go on studying it. In that moment Professor Risso advised me to
study with Maestro Abel Carlevaro. I admired him so much through his
recordings and concerts, that my first thought was that it would be
impossible to be accepted by him as a student. "Phone to him"
Risso told me, "he will open a new guitar world to you". So wise
words! I will be thankful to him for the rest of my life.
|
|
L.F.:
When did you meet Maestro Abel Carlevaro for the first time? Did
you know about his school? |
|
A.E.:
It was in 1974, in the same year in which he began to go to Europe again,
after his first european journey for about three years in the late
forties. I didn't know about his school, I only knew that his way of
playing was unique, so different from the rest of guitar players, and
which I liked as the best one.
|
|
L.F.:
Tell us about your first lessons with him, and your experiences with
his school. |
|
A.E.:
You can imagine how nervous I was when I took my first lesson with him!
But surely you would never imagine what I am going to tell you now. I went
there, ignoring totally what having a lesson with a great Maestro meant,
and I didn't bring my guitar. "Please sit down and take this guitar…But
be careful! It belonged to Segovia and I've just played a concert in Paris
with it!". It was his
Hauser!! A wonderful instrument, made in 1936. Well,
he asked me to play something, and I had prepared a Gavotte by Barrios (B
minor). After having played five or six bars, he stopped me very kindly:
"Very well, you've got good conditions… but I will tell you how to
sit down". And so Juan Carlos Risso was right: a new world was opened
to me. I had never dreamt that a guitar lesson could be so logical, clear
and deep in concepts. When I went back home, I bought a thick notebook and
began to write down every thing he told me in his lessons. I did so for
more than two years. Of course I still keep that notebook as a treasure,
even when those concepts have been so deeply developed in the books. My
experiences with the school are so many, and I am so concerned with it!
But I will tell you something that is for me a good resume of what it
means to me. A couple of months before that first lesson, I had read an
interview in which Carlevaro said -among other important things- something
you have surely already heard: "Practising is not so important as
thinking. Play one hour but think ten".
Amazing for me! So, when that first lesson finished, I asked him:
"What did you mean in that interview by 'thinking on the
guitar'?" And he answered "That is what I am going to teach
you". And this is now the most important of my experiences with his
school: I am now able to think on the guitar.
|
|
L.F.:
The Cuadernos 1-4 existed already. Did you already know them before you
met Maestro Carlevaro? Can you tell something about them, their ideas or
concepts? |
|
A.E.:
I already knew Cuadernos 1-3, and I had been practising on them for one
year before going to him, but without knowing the underlying concepts.
Useless! In that first lesson he not only taught me how to sit
down, but also how to play a C major scale to its slightest detail (you
know about this…) That
day he gave me Cuaderno Nº 4 too, because it had just been published. As
I told you, it is useless to practice on those Cuadernos without knowing
the main concepts of the school. For example, Cuaderno Nº 3 is focused on
the changes of position on the fingerboard. And, as you know, they are all
of them made by the arm. But if you are sitting in an incorrect way,
or if you don't know the concepts about how to take the instrument, it
will be impossible for you to move your arm freely, and most probably the
exercises will be wrongly made. A proper use of the Cuadernos need a very
careful reading of "Escuela de la Guitarra" or better, to have
lessons with somebody who really knows about these things.
|
|
L.F.:
In the “Escuela de la guitarra” we can read that Maestro Carlevaro
dictated the book to you. What is the history of this book? Whose idea was
it to write this book? When did you both start to work on it? What are
your contributions to it? |
|
A.E.:
Carlevaro has told me that in the early seventies, Alberto
Ginastera, the great argentinian composer, encouraged him to write a book
exposing his ideas about the guitar, after having heard his masterclasses
in Villa Gesell, Argentina. During the following years he made several
attempts to write it, having asked three or four different persons to help
him. But for several reasons it didn't work. Once, at the beginning of
1976, he told me about that and he even showed me four folders containing
some written pages about different subjects of the future book. Different
kinds of paper, different machine types, different handwriting…It was
evident that several persons had tried to help him. In that moment I
realised that it would be for me a wonderful opportunity for learning more
about the school if I could help him in that task. And I felt that I was
able to. Some
months later, in August, he came back from Europe and the first day I
visited him for my weekly lesson, he asked me: "You work in a bank,
don't you?" In fact, I did. "And then you know how to type
quickly and well." Of course I did. "Do you have some time now?
I have to talk something important with you". And, as I answered that
I had time, he said: "Let's go and have a coke". And then he
told me that he had realised in Europe that many students and guitar
players were using his "Cuadernos" without knowing how to do it,
and it was a very bad thing because the results were the opposite they
should be. "It is urgent to write the book", he told me.
"And I need your help, because you know how to type and you know my
ideas". Don’t forget, Leon, that in those days there were no
computers, and for me no electric-machine, so I typed on an old one, very
heavy, which had belonged to my father. Well,
we began to work on Wednesday, 1st September 1976. Once a week
we had a two-hours session (sometimes longer), beginning at 9 PM, in which
he spoke while I was writing down what he was saying. Several times we
discussed about the most clear ways of explaining something, and several
times I gave him the "external" point of view, that's to say,
how his hand or his arm, for example, looked from my point of view,
sitting in front of him. Then
I went back home and I had a whole week for putting those papers in order,
cleaning up the text, and then typing it. Back next Wednesday, I read it
loudly to him, and very often
new ideas came, or some corrections, and then back home to write it again!
Remember: no cut-copy-paste in those days! I wrote each chapter at least
five times! Writing the whole book took us more than eighteen months. The
pictures were taken at the end of March 1978, I made the drawings (because
the publisher had problems for getting a professional drawer) in May
and gave Barry the originals and everything in June '78. The
book finally appeared in August '79. I
would like to add two things: the first one is that as I had thought,
helping Carlevaro in writing this book was incredibly important for my own
learning and besides, it opened many new opportunities for my job of
teaching. The second one is that "Escuela de la Guitarra" was
the first book in which I worked with Carlevaro. After that, I helped him
in all the following books: the four "Masterclasses", and also
the Dictionary and a book about his own experiences with the guitar and
the music (both not yet published).
|
|
L.F.:
What are the most important values in the book “Escuela de la
Guitarra”? |
|
A.E.:
I think that its value for guitarists all over the world is shown by the
fact that it has been already published in six languages (Spanish,
English, French, German, Chinese and
Korean, this last one being not authorized by Maestro Carlevaro) and also
translated to Japanese, Czech and other languages. I don't know
whether any other book about the guitar, even the most famous methods,
have been so widely translated and published. Do you? But in any case, the
logics and the order in which the new ideas are exposed, in addition to
the huge changes respect to the most usual guitar techniques, make the
book so attractive to so many guitar players around the world. Consider
that there is no economic power behind it, no publicity-machine, Carlevaro
has no manager, he is not a member of the "star-system", he does
not record for any famous or powerful label. So, this book and Carlevaro's
teachings have opened their own way only because of their value…
|
|
L.F.:
What do you regard as special or new about this school? |
|
A.E.:
The fantastic equilibrium between logics, playing (and teaching)
experience, and a fine and deep conception of art and music. Besides, it
is the first time in which guitar playing is thought not from the fingers
action but from the whole body. Imagine that even the feet have their own
role! Nobody before Carlevaro had explained how to move the fingers on the
fingerboard using the arm and the wrist as the principal actors. When I
was a child, I was amazed every time I heard Carlevaro's recordings,
because of his clearness, and thought it was due to his extraordinary
ability. Now I know that any student who has learned how to use properly
his arm, can play without making any noise. But nobody had taught this
before him… And
the main thing: everything is focused on the music. Cleaning and making
easier the way of playing has the aim of putting the music in the first
level of attention. Think on what he says in the book: simplicity is the
result of an intelligently combined complex. A good technique, laying on a
real theory, simplifies playing and allows the music to come out freely.
|
|
L.F.:
Do you know whether there are many players using the concepts of the
school? |
|
A.E.:
Of course there are many. From many different parts of the world. And
those who have really understood it, don't want to play anymore in the
"old" way.
|
|
L.F.:
Could you tell us something about your work for the guitar in Uruguay?
About the guitar-association? About your television program? |
|
A.E.:
I try to teach these concepts to any guitarist who would like to know
about them. That is my job. And, as I told you, I like it very much. The
guitar association, Centro Guitarrístico del Uruguay, was founded in
1937, and organizes concerts and other activities. Since 1994 we have a
weekly TV program, in the National TV System, which is seen in the whole
country. You know it, because you visited the program last year, and
played in it. Many well known guitarists have been there, playing in the
TV studio: Abel Carlevaro, his brother Agustin, Pierri, Fernández,
Baranzano, Barbosa Lima, Eduardo Isaac, Alessio Monti, Cacho Tirao, Jorge
Oraison, José Miguel Moreno, Patrick Zeoli, Richard Stover, and many
others. And also many young Uruguayan players have their opportunity to
play there. Imagine that we've already made more than 300 programs! Once a
week, half an hour of good guitar, during more than six years…
|
|
L.F.:
Can you tell us something about Uruguay and the guitar? Who are the
important players? |
|
A.E.:
There is a very long history of the guitar in Uruguay: it has always been
the most popular instrument since
the time of the Spanish colony. And afterwards it began to develop when
very good guitarists came here: Manjón,
Calleja, García Tolsa,
the great Barrios, Segovia, who lived nine years in Montevideo. And
besides Carlevaro, there
are many well known names in Uruguayan guitar: Oscar Cáceres, Betho
Davezac, Antonio Pereira Arias, Baltazar Benítez, the most famous Pierri
and Fernández, José Fernández Bardesio, Jorge Oraison, Eduardo
Baranzano, César Amaro, Juan Carlos Amestoy, I cannot tell you all of
them…
|
|
L.F.:
One last question I would like to ask you. What are your future plans
in regard to the guitar and the guitar school of
Maestro Carlevaro? |
|
A.E.:
You know how much I like teaching and principally the things I've learned
from Maestro Carlevaro. These are always my plans: trying to teach anybody
who is interested in these subjects, here in Montevideo or in any part of
the world where I would be invited to go. And, from time to time, giving
some concert so as not to lose the practice.
|
|
L.F.:
Alfredo, thank you very much for your inspiring words. I’m already
looking forward to the concert of Maestro
Abel Carlevaro in Diekirch. I wish you all the best and hope that the
members of our guitar club Cithara will
meet you one time in Luxemburg! |
The
Concert of Maestro Abel Carlevaro, organized by the guitar club Cithara, will be
in Diekirch (Luxemburg) on the 19th of May 2001 at 20:00h in the old
church of Saint Laurent.
-Cuaderno No.1: Escalas
diatónicas (1966, Barry, Buenos Aires)
-Cuaderno No.2: Técnica
de la mano derecha (1967, Barry, Buenos Aires)
-Cuaderno No.3 : Técnica
de la mano izquierda (1969, Barry, Buenos Aires)
-Cuaderno No.4 : Técnica
de la mano izquierda (conclusión) (1974, Barry, Buenos Aires)
Escuela de
la guitara Exposición
de la teoría instrumental
(1978, Dacisa,
Montevideo/Barry, Buenos Aires) ;
in German : Schule der Gitarre Darstellung
der instrumentalen Theorie (1998, Chanterelle, Heidelberg)
Volume
I: 10 Studies by Fernando Sor (1985, Chanterelle)
Volume
II: 5 Preludes & Chôro no.1 by Heitor Villa-Lobos (1987, Chanterelle)
Volume
III: 12 Studies by Heitor Villa-Lobos (1988, Chanterelle)
Volume
IV: Chaconne BWV 1004 by J.S. Bach (1989, Chanterelle 714)